Home / News / Article
CyberScoop · 4 min read

Senate Republicans advance FCC nominee, slate of cyber bills 

Republicans in the Senate Commerce Committee advanced the nomination of Danielle Thumann Severs to serve as a commissioner at the Federal Communications Commission.

Alongside Severs’ nomination, the GOP majority also voted favorably on a slew of tech and cybersecurity bills. But Democrats – who will wield the majority gavel in January – boycotted the hearing, throwing the fate of the bills into question, even as many had bipartisan sponsorship.

If confirmed, Thumann Severs would give Republicans and chair Brendan Carr a 3-1 majority on the commission, with Biden administration holdover Anna Gomez the only remaining Democrat. The Trump administration has not moved to fire Gomez as it did two Democratic commissioners on the Federal Trade Commission last year. But he also broke with precedent by declining to name a Democratic-appointee alongside Thumann Severs to round out the five-member commission.

In a hearing room that sat half-empty on the Democratic side, committee chair Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas defended the decision to move forward with Thumann Severs’ nomination after resounding losses in the midterm elections.

“What it should tell us is that the Democrats have zero intention of processing any of the president’s nominees,” Cruz said. “We are heading into two years of total destruction, total war, partisan warfare is what the Democrats are promising us.”

He argued President Donald Trump is not legally required to nominate FCC commissioners in pairs, and is merely to elect no more than three members of the same party. The nomination of Thumann Severs, he claimed, is “consistent with that requirement.”

He also suggested that President Trump had demonstrated a desire for the commission to remain bipartisan by declining to fire Gomez after the Supreme Court upheld his right to do so to FTC commissioners last year.

CyberScoop has reached out to Democrats on the Senate Commerce Committee for comment. On Tuesday committee member Sen. Ben Ray Luján, D-N.M., accused Thumann Severs of not being forthcoming about her role in support of Carr’s media bias investigations.

Republicans on the committee also advanced multiple tech and cybersecurity-related bills.

The COLLUDE Act, sponsored by Sen. Eric Schmitt, R-Mo., would create a private right to sue social media companies that make content moderation decisions based on government requests. Specifically, the bill would strip liability protections under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act for social media companies, opening them to private lawsuits from individuals if their account or post bans

As Missouri Attorney General, Schmitt led a lawsuit over the Biden administration’s information sharing with social media companies around COVID-19 and election disinformation. That case eventually reached the Supreme Court, where the majority concluded that the communications were non-coercive and that social media companies have their own, constitutionally-protected incentives for moderating speech on their platforms.

Under the Trump administration and Carr, the FCC has gone considerably further than the Biden administration in attempting to police political speech over the public airwaves, opening investigations into broadcast media organizations that have aired interviews with Democratic opponents and at times likening their perceived disagreement with the federal government as evidence of broadcasting undue ideological bias. Thumann Severs served as Carr’s senior counsel prior to being nominated as FCC commissioner.

When moving forward Thumann Severs’ nomination earlier in the meeting, Cruz and other Republicans gave only verbal commitments to hold the FCC accountable for its mission to protect free speech.

Another bill, the Telecommunications Cybersecurity and Resilience Act, sponsored by Cruz and Sen. Mark Warner, D-Va., would establish a telecommunications cybersecurity working group at the Department of Commerce that would be charged with developing industry best practices around cybersecurity and develop criteria for independent third-party cybersecurity certifications and assessors.

The bill comes at the end of the first congressional session since U.S. policymakers were notified that a Chinese hacking group called Salt Typhoon had systematically infiltrated U.S. telecommunications infrastructure and spied on high level U.S. officials, including then-incoming Vice President J.D. Vance.

But both Congress and the FCC opted against new legislation or regulation to improve the status quo, instead touting voluntary partnerships that they claim have led to material improvements in cybersecurity across the sector since the Salt Typhoon hacks. Earlier this year, the FCC rescinded new regulatory requirements that were put in place during the final months of the Biden administration.

The Chip EQUIP Act, introduced by Sen. Mark Kelly, D-Ariz., and Marsha Blackburn, R-Tenn.,  would require companies that receive federal funding under the 2022 CHIPS Act to sign a ten year agreement prohibiting the money from being used to procure, install or use of semiconductor manufacturing equipment produced by companies owned or controlled by China, Russia, Iran or North Korea. U.S. chipmaker NVidia  is currently embroiled in an investigation over more than $12 billion in alleged chip sales, some of which may have been diverted to China.

Originally published on CyberScoop