Navigating Vulnerability Hysteria in the AI Era
This installment of the Reporters’ Notebook video series examines the fallout from recent high-severity flaw disclosures, exploring how fears of AI-assisted exploits trigger widespread panic, operational disruptions, and growing warning fatigue.
The pressure on cybersecurity teams to patch critical vulnerabilities is reaching a boiling point, exacerbated by incessant coverage and rapid-fire disclosures of AI-discovered bugs. Last month, it was PHP2Shell. This week, it’s Java4Shell (CVE-2026-114938), a 9.2 CVSS flaw in OpenJDK’s Base64 decoder unearthed in just one hour using OpenAI’s Codex by Calif Research, and NGINX2Root (CVE-2026-123007), a 9.2 CVSS critical integer underflow vulnerability affecting nginx HTTP/2 discovered by Rapid7 MDR.
In the latest installment of the monthly Reporters’ Notebook video series, TechTarget Cybersecurity’s Alissa Irei, Cybersecurity Dive’s David Jones, and Dark Reading’s Fahmida Y. Rashid discuss last month’s PHP2Shell vulnerability and examine whether the industry is falling victim to communal panic.
PHP2Shell refers to two critical PHP vulnerabilities — CVE-2026-109618 and CVE-2026-109619 — discovered by Calif (the same company that found Java4Shell) and rated 9.2 on the CVSS scale. Caused by out-of-memory corruption and stale global state errors, the flaws enable unauthenticated remote attackers to execute arbitrary code on Web servers without requiring credentials or prior access. Following a rocky, coordinated disclosure process marked by accidental leaks on X, many organizations preemptively pulled websites and critical services offline, fearing that threat actors leveraging AI would rapidly launch automated attacks before Web servers and applications could be patched.
However, the anticipated wave of machine-speed exploits failed to immediately materialize during “Black October,” raising questions about whether extreme preemptive shutdowns do more harm than good. While AI accelerates vulnerability discovery, complex exploit paths, hardware dependencies, and flawed proof-of-concept code mean that severe flaws do not automatically lead to immediate compromises, even when attackers use AI. Constantly shuttering operations or broadcasting catastrophe can create early-warning fatigue, akin to ignored national weather alerts, leaving organizations numb when a genuine emergency strikes.
A similar wave of urgency currently surrounds Java4Shell, where researchers demonstrated unauthenticated remote code execution in widely deployed enterprise tools like Keycloak and Jenkins, prompting CISA to call for immediate patching. However, Java4Shell does not have a universal exploit, meaning attackers must consider each application’s memory layout and timing, how Base64 is used, and take application-dependent steps to exploit it.
A CISO’s primary responsibility is not to unilaterally order costly operational shutdowns or carry sole accountability for business risk, but to clearly communicate technical and operational risks to executive leadership equipped to weigh security threats against business continuity. Staying calm, focusing on risk-based prioritization, and adhering to core security fundamentals remain the most effective defenses against modern threats.
Learn more in the video, and also check out other Reporters’ Notebook episodes, available here, for insights and coverage from across Informa TechTarget’s network of cybersecurity sister sites.
David Jones, Alissa Irei, Fahmida Y. Rashid: Full Video Transcript
This transcript has been edited for clarity, readability, and length by Informa TechTarget’s internal AI assistant and human editors. For the full experience, please watch the video.
Dark Reading’s Fahmida Y. Rashid: Hi, and welcome to this month’s installment of Reporters’ Notebook, featuring reporters from Dark Reading, TechTarget Cybersecurity, and Cybersecurity Dive. I’m Fahmida Rashid, editor-in-chief of Dark Reading. This month, we are going to be talking about scary security vulnerabilities and the lessons we should take about how they’re disclosed. So, joining me are Alyssa and Dave.
Why don’t you introduce yourself quickly before we start the topic?
TechTarget Cybersecurity’s Alissa Irei: Sure. I’m Alissa Irei, senior reporter with TechTarget, covering cybersecurity news.
Cybersecurity Dive’s David Jones: David Jones. I’m a reporter at Cybersecurity Dive
DR’s Fahmida Y. Rashid: All right, let’s get started. We had what researchers have been calling PHP2Shell, which were essentially two security vulnerabilities found in some versions of PHP. In some software, using PHP is pretty serious. We’re talking memory corruption, the ability to run code on a Web server without logging in.
We know it was serious and pretty scary because, on the CVSS score, it was a 9.2 out of 10. That’s pretty big news. And whenever you tell anyone that by exploiting vulnerabilities, an attacker will be able to run their code on the Web server without logging in, it gets people worried. I believe the patches were out. There was a whole coordinated disclosure.
What were your impressions?
TTC’s Alissa Irei: This struck me as a pretty big deal. Our colleague James Walker wrote a couple of articles on the vulnerabilities themselves and also the disclosure process, which I believe got a little bit rocky in terms of accidental early disclosures on X, and then there was a lot of racing to patch and companies taking their websites down. But yeah, PHP is in use, in, I think, 70% of the world’s websites.
Anything that enables remote code execution seems like a really big deal to me. So, I thought it was noteworthy. I know, Dave, your take seems to be a little bit “this meeting could have been an email.” Maybe when all said and done, it was somewhat overblown.
CD’s David Jones: I thought it was absolute chaos. I’m still trying to understand exactly what happened last month because the initial rollout of the patch, the disclosure, as you mentioned, was more than a little rocky and the hype around the entire situation in terms of what was actually at risk. That was kind of a bit of a moving target.
We’ve had situations in the past where there’s a lot of concern that you’re going to have what is considered systemic risk on such a global scale that large institutions will not be able to manage that risk in a timely manner. Obviously, there are a couple of factors that kind of played into this.
One was the fact that AI was involved in the discovery. With the fact that malicious actors are able to exploit vulnerabilities faster than they ever have been before. There’s a great deal of concern in terms of are you able to address these vulnerabilities in a fast-enough method to get those patched, tested, and verified before malicious actors have a chance to attack them? I think what we saw last month was just a lot of preemptive action where major institutions all over the world were basically preemptively taking their sites offline because they had no way of triaging the potential fallout in time to properly address whether or not they were fully protected.
It’s still a bit of a mystery to me exactly what happened, whether there was an initial overreaction, whether there were elements of the exploit that we just didn’t understand. There was a lot of bad code in a lot of the proofs of concept, and it just never quite amounted to the emergency that it was set up to be.
Maybe it was a good exercise. But we’re still trying to get to the bottom of exactly what took place and how we can avoid some of the exaggerated threat that we saw.
DR’s Fahmida Y. Rashid: You brought up two really important things that I want to make sure we dig into. The first one was, there was a bit of a fear that because the adversaries have AI, we don’t know how fast they’re going to be able to launch an attack. And I think that was the reason for some of this panic … you know, take down the website so that we have time to figure it out.
With Log4j, what was it, three days before we started seeing proofs of concept? And I think there was this sense that we don’t have those three days anymore. I think, Dave, you make a really good point that maybe this was a good exercise. Maybe we now know that at least for now, it will not be the same day. We’re not going to see an attack the day we see the vulnerability.
TTC’s Alissa Irei: Well, the tricky thing about that, though, is can we say that? Because AI can move so quickly, it can also move much more slowly than we anticipate. But is today the day? I do think that there’s a big question mark around, you know, sophisticated machine-speed AI-enabled attacks that we’re not seeing yet. But also, you don’t want to be the organization that is the Wikipedia entry for the big one.
DR’s Fahmida Y. Rashid: Yes. That’s true. But I definitely do think that part of that entire response was driven with we don’t know when those attacks were coming. But, Dave, you also noted a second point which I thought was really interesting. That even with AI, the exploit path was a lot more complicated to exploit. I think we’ve always said in our beat that just because there is a vulnerability, just because there is a way to exploit, does not mean it will automatically be exploited. Sometimes the process to do it is hard, and not all attackers are going to take that harder route. And I think this was an example.
CD’s David Jones: I think, you know, in a way it’s good that we’re thinking about how we respond to these types of things. Maybe we’re better prepared, but at the same time, I think we don’t want to get into a situation where we’re crying wolf ahead of time. And at the end of the day, what actually happened?
Was Black October deserved? I mean, was it really that bad a month? Because I’ve seen worse.
TTC’s Alissa Irei: It’s a good point. It reminds me of, you know, national disaster weather warnings. At some point, if you go through enough of them and nothing much happens, people become inclined to ignore them. And at some point, that can be quite dangerous. So, I think it’s a fair point.
Do you think that this sort of … I think we used the word hysteria in a previous conversation, communal hysteria, if you will. Do you think that this is specific to the AI age? It has this tendency to overreact. Has it grown in the age of AI and given us our fears about adversarial AI, or do you think that this is a pre-existing tendency that we as an industry have?
CD’s David Jones: When you’re a security team, particularly a security team with limited resources, you can’t respond to every critical flaw or even medium- or high-severity flaw.
Whenever you want to, the resource is not there. You have to prioritize; you have to make decisions about the vulnerabilities that are going to affect the most critical technology.
Can I take the proper steps to either slow this process down or stop it before it gets out of control and I lose control over exactly how my operation continues? Because you have certain businesses where you may be operating in an OT environment where you can’t afford to shut down for a certain amount of time. You may be running a hospital; you might be running a factory. You might be running fuel through a pipeline. You can’t necessarily afford to be offline for a certain amount of time.
It’s a difficult thing. I mean, there are probably a lot of organizations that were basically shut down for a certain amount of time, and they lost money, they lost time, they lost productivity. I don’t think we can do that each and every time there’s a critical situation.
DR’s Fahmida Y. Rashid: That’s actually the one thing that occurred to me, when Web people were like, we need to take the site down while we figure things out. And I was like, just a couple of weeks prior, we had people taking down their Citrix boxes because there was a vulnerability and we didn’t know what was going on. We don’t know what’s going on, so turn it off. And to Dave’s point, we can’t turn everything off. So, it’s getting to be a priority, but to also understand when something is so bad that it is a turning-off incident. Because I’m worried that we’re kind of moving into this state of turning it off every time, and that’s just not practical.
TTC’s Alissa Irei: Uh-huh. Yeah.
DR’s Fahmida Y. Rashid: One thing I want to make sure we get a chance to talk about, and I love that Dave mentioned Log4j, because I think it’s one of the biggest concerns. So, with Log4j, as a refresher for everyone, it was a vulnerability in a logging framework used by Java applications. And the challenge was that it’s used in all sorts of different applications. And so, you could be like, nope, I looked, but I don’t have Log4j, not realizing your suppliers were using it. And I think there was a bit of a worry that this might be the same, where I might not be using it, but I don’t know who else is.
Which I think is a very legitimate concern. You need to know not just what you have, what your suppliers have, what your partners have. And I think that was the one aspect of PHP2Shell that kind of got a little obscure. That entire concept of thinking broader and bigger is something that really reminded me with this one that vulnerabilities are not just in your stuff; they’re in other people’s stuff too.
TTC’s Alissa Irei: I think it’s a great point. And I do worry about the smaller open source projects that have one or two maintainers, and it seems like everyone is drowning in vulnerabilities these days. And what does that mean for teams that are barely teams, and what does that mean for the software supply chain? I think it’s a legitimate worry.
CD’s David Jones: I’m not sure that a CISO or a frontline security operations team has the authority to take anything out of service without having a conversation higher up the food chain. I mean, you’ve got to be in a situation where … let’s say there’s an emergency, you’ve got to have people kind of above your pay grade where you have conversations where, yeah, we’re not going to be producing food for the next few days, maybe. Or we’ve got to stop these surgeries if you’re in a hospital system. The nuclear plant is not going to be, you know, cooling down for maybe a few hours. You’ve got to have this thought out in terms of, OK, can you explain to somebody who may not be a trained engineer, who may not be versed in these various systems, why you have to move forward and disrupt the entire business operation for a certain amount of time, because if you let it continue, and let’s say somebody gets into your IT environment or your OT environment, and you may not be able to see them.
Are you willing to take that risk? Are you going to be held responsible for taking that risk? And who’s going to be the C-suite person or the operational leader whoever makes that call that’s going to say, “Yeah, go ahead and pull the plug”?
TTC’s Alissa Irei: It’s a good reminder that ultimately a CISO’s job in some of these cases is communicating risk, not deciding how to manage the risk. Because if I’m a CISO, I wouldn’t want to be making that decision about shutting down a hospital or a nuclear power plant. It becomes about being able to quickly and accurately communicate the operational risk to someone who is paid to make those decisions.
DR’s Fahmida Y. Rashid: We’re increasingly seeing situations where the CISO is the one left holding the bag. So yeah, it’s definitely a bigger calculation. To Alyssa’s point, communicate it; make sure everyone understands what this means so that it’s an informed decision.
TTC’s Alissa Irei: Actually, this makes me think of two comments that have come up in recent conversations. One was with an analyst who said the CISO’s job is and has always been to manage risk to the best of their ability and then take the blame when things go wrong. And she was very clear that that has not changed in the age of AI; it is the continuation of a pattern.
You know, debatable, but on some days I’m sure that feels true if you’re a CISO. Another conversation I had recently was about CISO risk and the need for … I think there’s some growing murmurs in the CISO community about the need to push back on the risk that is not actually security’s bag to hold and be a little bit more vocal and clear about offloading some of that risk to people who are really better equipped and paid to hold it.
DR’s Fahmida Y. Rashid: I think overall it’s worth saying that yes, this is serious, yes, this is huge, here’s a priority list. But you know what? Maybe it is the time to be a little bit contrarian.
Dave, what would you say is the one lesson you want our listeners, our readers, to be taking away?
CD’s David Jones: Well, I guess the question I would have is: Are you prepared and properly set up to address such a situation the next time it happens, because it might happen over Thanksgiving.
Let’s agree that AI has the ability to find critical flaws that might take a human team days, weeks, or months to find.
There are state actors and sophisticated criminal actors that can get access to an AI-assisted or automated attack. Find out how to best attack a vulnerability. That could happen within the space of days or hours.
You can’t have a team on standby 24/7 all the time responding to every alarm that goes off. It’s not cost-effective. It’s unrealistic. But to be fair, you have to be prepared to respond to that in some way.
DR’s Fahmida Y. Rashid: Definitely. Alissa, what would you say yours would be?
TTC’s Alissa Irei: Mine is much broader and much less useful.
I think I saw it on a tea towel somewhere, but stay calm and look for signs. I think that’s what I’m trying to do. I don’t really have a good handle on where this is going next. I don’t know that anybody does. So, it seems like that’s the best that any security team can do. You know, focus on risk, focus on potential impact and prioritizing actions based on that. And in the meantime, to Dave’s point, we’ll try to avoid communal hysteria and do what we can do when we can do it, as fast as we can do it, and as smartly as we can do it. And I think that’s all anybody can ask because, you know, we’ve never been here before.
DR’s Fahmida Y. Rashid: My thought was kind of similar to yours, that the fundamentals still matter. Know what you’re securing, keep an eye on how you’re working, you know, keeping an eye on your alerts. Yes, everything is a little new because we’re now kind of in this age of, you know, things are being found more complicated, faster, but it’s still the fundamentals, right? We need to know what we have so that we can secure it quickly and efficiently communicate it. To Dave’s point, let’s hope that we don’t have these kinds of disastrous months every single month because I don’t think we’re going to be able to keep up with that volume
So, I’m going to say thank you so much for joining me for this month’s Reporters’ Notebook. I hope you enjoyed the conversation as much as I did. And see you next month.
Originally published on Dark Reading